Meeting the motor drive challenge of power tool design

Meeting the motor drive challenge of power tool design

In common with many products, the challenges for power tool designers are ramping up. With users wanting lighter tools with greater run-time at a lower cost, there are some fundamental changes in the technologies being employed.  

For many years, brushed motors have been the mainstay. They are simple to use and easy to power but, on the downside, they are relatively inefficient and the brushes are a weak spot as they arc and cause EMI, as well as wearing, thereby requiring maintenance.  

Brushless DC motors (BLDC) are becoming popular for several reasons. Firstly, they offer better efficiency (up to 15% better than brushed motors) and offer more rotational power for a given size. Additionally, they can offer a wider speed range and are quieter – both electrically and mechanically. All these benefits allow the development of better power tools. However, while it is relatively simple to make a BLDC motor rotate, driving it properly is somewhat of a challenge that must be overcome.  

To control a BLDC motor, the DC supply must be converted to a 3-phase signal to drive the 3 stator windings. In some cases, a position feedback sensor is also required. The voltage and frequency of the 3-phase waveform controls the rotational speed and the current is proportional to the torque. The frequency must be high enough so as not to cause audible noise yet not so high that losses in the transistors become excessive – typically a few tens of kilohertz are used.  

There are many methods of driving a BLDC motor, relating to the shape of the AC waveform. The simplest is trapezoidal where two windings are energized and the third is open circuit. This provides a rotational force which moves the rotor although, due to the simple shape of the square wave drive, some ripple is present in the torque which can lead to vibration and noise at low speeds.  

The torque ripple can be eliminated by using a sine-wave drive (‘sinusoidal commutation’) although this is more complex, requiring a microcontroller to generate the sine waves. It also requires higher precision in the position sensing.  

Nowadays, Vector or Field-Oriented Control (FOC) is becoming far more commonplace as it delivers smooth operation over the whole speed range, fast acceleration and deceleration and 100% torque at zero speed. It can operate with position sensors but, equally there are sensorless techniques available.  

However, FOC requires some complex mathematical calculations to be performed constantly, allowing the orthogonal components of the field flux linkage and torque to be derived and controlled. Even simple FOC controllers can be quite complex requiring a pulse width modulator (PWM), software-based PI control, ADCs and a vector-capable processor. Many microcontrollers lack the instruction set for this while DSPs have the instruction set but insufficient I/O capability.  

Toshiba’s Advanced Vector Engine (A-VE) is a dedicated FOC controller that is based upon the ARM Cortex-M4 microcontroller platform. Part of the M4K group of devices in the TXZ4 series, the device has the capability to provide FOC to two motors, with processing capacity to spare.  

To find out how Toshiba’s A-VE devices can take the strain of driving BLDC motors in demanding applications such as power tools, please download our white paper that gives a full overview of the considerations necessary for modern motor control:


A new window will open